indian-knowledge-systems

Are the Vedas Internally Consistent? On the Conceptual Integrity of India's Texts

saketposwal.com

The Question Worth Asking

A common charge against the Indian textual tradition is that it is a contradictory heap—Vedas that ritualise, Upanishads that renounce, Darshanas that argue, Tantras that transgres…

Layers, Not Contradictions

Start with the sense of contradiction and it usually dissolves into a sense of level.

The Guardrail: Pramana

Here is what makes the coherence more than a comforting story. The tradition did not merely assert that its knowledge held together.

Where Tantra Fits

The hardest case for the "coherent architecture" claim is Tantra, which can look like a rebellion against Vedic order.

Read the full article

The Vedas, Upanishads, Darshanas and Tantras look like a contradictory pile of texts. Look closer and a single coherent architecture appears. Here is how it holds together.

saketposwal.com